So, I think my standards of awesome are just higher than everyone else’s. I mean, I would recommend Irredeemable because it’s interesting, not because it’s awesome. Let’s get to that, shall we?
The very first thing I want to mention is that it’s five issues in right now. The first four issues are out in a small trade paper back priced at $9.99 (US) and the fifth issue is only $0.99 (US), so you can catch up on the series for a whopping twelve bucks and some change. That’s pretty nice, in my opinion.
Drawn by Peter Krause and colored by Andrew Dalhouse, the book looks just fine. The art is respectable, the colors are acceptable. Nothing out of the ordinary going on in the book, however - it’s pretty status quo visually.
It’s written by Mark Waid. Now, I think he’s going a credible job telling the story of a Superman-like character who’s gone complely off his rocker. I’m just not sure I like how the comic starts with him completely off his rocker. I feel like the story would have been seriously cooler if we’d have say, twelve to twenty issues to get to know The Plutonian as a hero before he starts in with the villainy. That would have required, of course, a longer contract and, possibly, a steadier fanbase. At least with a miniseries you’ve got a set number of issues that are very likely to see full publication, so I don’t really think I can blame anyone for picking this style of publication.
The characters are supposed to be remenescent of characters from the big-name ‘verses, and they do an okay job at that. But the story only carries real weight when you are actively super-imposing the real characters on top of Waid’s - again because we haven’t gotten to know them. I’d be interested to know if this was something Waid planned on the audience doing or not.
There are a lot of great snippets of dialogue in the book, and Waid also manages to point out some serious issues with Superman’s abilities and storyline. For example The Plutonian can hear everyone in the world (just like Superman), but he ends up dwelling on the nasty things that are being said about him rather than the good things.
My favorite part of issue five is when The Plutonian does a world-wide broadcast about his “fan-mail,” which is really just all of the things he’s overheard.
The Plutonian: And, finally, Caleb Albright of Vancouver, BC– And, by the way, Caleb, yes, it is cancer– wrote in his journal, “Who does he think he is?” Funny you should ask. You know what they used to say about the gods of myth. That they would disguise themselves and walk among you as ordinary men. I confess, I do that. It’s enlightening. But… Who am I? That guy down at the end of the bar? The new recruit? The foreigner who just moved in upstairs? I know what you’re thinking. That at least in this moment, I can’t be standing next to you. There is that. But I should add one thing. This has been a pre-recorded message. Sleep tight.
Waid really manages to capture the sheer creep-factor in a super-villain who can overhear anything you say. And I have to admit, it makes me look forward to the future issues. But I still can’t shake the wish that the series as a whole could have come out of a long-standing title.
It’s too bad DC won’t ever let anyone do that to Superman in the canon storyline, right?
Worth a Pick Up? Yes. Definitely.
I’m going to do my best to keep up a small, weekly tradition. My boss is having us take home comics on Tuesday night that won’t be released until Wednesday and read them so we can converse with the customers about them. This is absolutely necessary, because apparently working at a comics shop requires that you know everything there is to know about every comic on your shelf. (How anyone can assume you read every title from start to finish is beyond me.)
That being said, I’m going to try to write short reviews of each of the books I bring home. Nothing fancy, just my quick impressions. So, here goes:
Buffy the Vampire Slayer #27
This is the second issue of the Retreat arc written by Jane Espenson. I was looking forward to Oz’s return in this issue, but ended up a little disappointed. I’m not sure I like where he ended up, having settled down to a family. I’m even less sure I appreciate the apparent jealousy issues Willow is exhibiting toward said family. If you’re going to make a character gay, make her gay. Georges Jeanty does the art, inked by Andy Owens. I’m not sure I like some of the dramatic inking that was done with Jeanty’s art this issue - at times I had trouble figuring out who some of the characters were. This, combined with some pretty bland statements from a ton of characters led to some serious re-reading.
Worth a Pick Up? Yes, if you’re already knee-deep in the story. No, if you’re just coming in.
Deadpool: Merc With a Mouth #2
I read this in conjunction with issue #1. I know that a lot of people love Deadpool. He’s both dangerous and hilarious at the same time - win/win. I loved the art (Bong Dazo), the inks (Jose Pimentel) and the colors (Matt Milla) in this book a lot. I thought they suited the silliness that seems inherent in a guy meeting his decapitated zombie head from another dimension. Speaking of that, I also loved the premise. It seemed like the script (Victor Gischler) would have to be awesome, but it was really just kind of lame. The jokes were terrible and it wasn’t a very smooth read. Gischler could have done better, and I can’t help but feel that the editor (Axel Alonso) should have helped him in that regards.
Worth a Pick Up? Not in my opinion.
Iron man and the Armor Wars #1 of 4
This is a four issue reimagining of the original seven issue Iron Wars arc. It’s written by Joe Caramagna, and I think he does an okay job. I don’t think the issue is terribly witty in any way and he does try to tickle your ribs a little here and there. Shame it didn’t work out for him. Craig Rousseau does the drawing, and I like the style but it’s very cartoony and I’m not sure it’s suited to the storyline. The coloring (Van Staples) is bright and simple, pairing off nicely with the art - but again, not suited to the storyline. What I liked best about the issue was the cover; Skottie Young’s style is very interesting.
Worth a Pick Up? Eh. Maybe.
The Red Circle: The Hangman 1 Shot
Written my JMS, I was intrigued. The story is pretty standard, in my opion. “Hey look, here’s a super hero and his background.” The art (Tom Derenick) is often messy (but not bad) and the colors (Guy Major) are bright and appealing. I thought Bill Sienkiewicz did a great job inking, considering how messy the art looked (although one can’t always tell how much was the artist and how much was the inker). I was mostly frustrated that this was a one shot; the story didn’t end in a way that suited that length. If there were to be an issue #2 I’d read it, but as it stands I’m less than thrilled.
Worth a Pick Up? No, unless you’re fine with the one shot being a cliffhanger.
Star Wars: Dark Times #0
I picked this up because it was a #0. I don’t read all of the Star Wars titles (both for monetary and taste reasons), and I wasn’t sure if I’d like this one. I’m still not. It follows the exploits of Dass Jennir during the Rise of the Empire period (after Episode III, before Episode IV). The art (Douglas Wheatley) is gritty and full of depth on it’s own. This worked well for the seedy storyline, and was bolstered by darker coloring (Dave McCaig). I felt like the script (Mick Harrison) was rather lousey, but possibly only because they’re setting so much up in sixteen pages (the remainder of the book is a collection of sketches and the uninked layouts). I’m going to reserve final judgement of the title for issue #1.
Worth a Pick Up? Maybe, if you like Star Wars. I’d urge to hold out for issue #1.
Star Wars: Invasion #2
I was and still am extremely excited about this book. I’m an avid Star Wars fan and have been following the books for some time. I adamantly agree with the idea that the Yuuzhan Vong war holds a lot more potential than what was used up in the novels. That being said, I think pretty much everything about this book has been excellent so far. The writing Tom Taylor does is sound, though I feel like there aren’t enough pages to cover everything thoroughly (this may be eradicated when the issues are read as an arc all together rather than monthly). The art (Colin Wilson) is clean, but dynamic and you can actually recognize the stock characters (sometimes Luke just doesn’t look like Luke). The colors (Wes Dzioba) are very well done and add some serious depth to the various shots. What I like best about them is that they aren’t dramatically blended the way a lot of digital work is these days, so you still see gradient lines (I don’t know why that’s a positive for me, actually).
Worth a Pick Up? Yes, even if you haven’t read #1. But if you can find a copy, do grab that first issue.
So, this is a week late. Still, it’s worth reviewing simply because I’ve missed so many issues in the current run and I jumped back in with this one.
Writer: Gail Simone
Comments: Gail Simone is well known for being witty and fun to read. She doesn’t disappoint in this issue, slipping in some zingers on comic tropes (the fireman carry across the world that heroes like Superman like to perform on non-flying female friends) and a subtle jab at the reputation Amazons have as being big fat lesbos.
Artist: Aaron Lopresti
Comments: I’m not overly fond of Lopresti’s Diana, but his work is clean and easy to understand. I don’t feel like he’s just recycling another artist’s take on the characters, either.
Inker: Matt Ryan
Colorist: Brian Anderson
Comments: Inkers and Colorists have to work well together, and I’m not sure I’m feeling it in this issue. The coloring is obviously being done digitally - it’s a waste of time to do it any other way, these days - but the ink shading is better suited to more traditional coloring choices. Some cross hatching is unnecessary, for example, because the shading is so dynamic when digitally done.
I felt like the story was easy to understand, even not having read any issues in more than a year. Diana is no longer a member of the Amazons; she left because Zeus has placed himself at the top of the God puppy pile and instated a male leader on Themyscira. I don’t know why any of this has happened, but it has.
Apparently Black Canary has left the JLA, which Wonder Woman comments on having caused contention between them. Still, they manage to act like adults and work on a job together.
I felt like their interactions were very feminine, but almost too silly. I enjoyed reading their banter immensely, but have to wonder at whether they would both be so easily blithe after so much upheavel in the DC universe as of late. It is worth noting that Black Canary is almost always the one doing the jabbing, while Wonder Woman is almost always the jab-ee.
I’m going to wait to comment on the story arc they’re setting up here until I see the next issue, except to say that I find it promising. I really enjoyed this issue overall, as opposed to some comics which save their major impact moment for the very end of an issue.
Worth a Pick Up? Yes.